Select Page

Sibling Living Rent-Free in the Inherited House in Florida? Your Options

Florida courts rarely make a co-owner pay rent just for living there. Here's what does change things, and how families get to a buyout or a sale.
Voted Best Real Estate Group

Quick Answer: In Florida, once siblings own an inherited house together, the one living there generally doesn’t owe the others rent just for living there. Florida courts require ouster, meaning the sibling in the house shut the others out or claimed the house as their own and let them know. A Florida appeals court reaffirmed that rule in 2025 in Seaborn v. Seaborn. Things change if the house is still in a probate estate or trust, if the sibling rents it out, or if the sibling asks the others to share the taxes and mortgage, because the court can then weigh the rental value. Most families end with a buyout or a sale, and a partition case is the backstop. The Building Buyer buys inherited houses with an occupant still living there, pays all closing costs, and can often close in under 30 days once everyone who needs to sign is ready. Hablamos español.

Disclaimer: This article is general information, not legal advice. Rent, credits and possession between heirs depend on whether the house is still in an estate or trust, how title is held, and the facts of your family. Talk to a Florida probate or real estate attorney about your situation. If you need a probate attorney, we can recommend one for you, and the attorney is only paid once the home is sold.
Dylan Troiano, co-founder of The Building Buyer

Written by

Dylan Troiano

Co-founder, The Building Buyer

Dylan co-founded The Building Buyer, which buys probate and inherited houses across Florida as-is. He works with personal representatives, heirs, and their probate attorneys every week to get inherited homes sold and closed.

Who owns the house right now?

Before anyone talks about rent, figure out who holds title today. There are three common situations:

  • Still in the parent’s name, in probate or not yet probated. The house is part of the estate. A personal representative (Florida’s word for an executor) may have rights over it, as explained below.
  • Held in a trust. The trustee controls it for the beneficiaries.
  • Already in the siblings’ names. After a court order, a deed from the estate or trust, or a Lady Bird deed, siblings usually own it together as tenants in common. Each one owns a share of the whole house, and each one has the right to use all of it.

Pull the deed from the county’s official records, and ask the probate attorney whether any order or deed has already moved title.

Does a sibling owe rent for living there?

Usually not, once you own it together. The Florida Supreme Court explained the rule in Barrow v. Barrow (1988): a co-owner who has exclusive possession and uses the property for their own benefit, without collecting rents or profits from it, isn’t liable to the other co-owners unless they hold it adversely, or there was an ouster or its equivalent. Possession by one co-owner is presumed to be possession for all of them until the one in the house tells the others they claim it exclusively.

In Seaborn v. Seaborn, 413 So. 3d 989 (Fla. 2d DCA 2025), a sister lived alone in the home she and her brother inherited from their mother. The trial court ordered the house sold and gave the brother about $117,000 for back rent. The appeals court kept the sale but reversed the rent award, because he hadn’t alleged or proved ouster, and sole occupancy alone isn’t enough. It also noted that while the house was held in the trust, any rent would have been owed to the trust, not to him, and that rent between co-owners could only start once the co-ownership began.

What can count as ouster? Generally, acts that are inconsistent with the other owners’ rights and that they know about, such as changing the locks and refusing to let siblings in, or telling them the house is “mine now.” Whether specific facts amount to ouster is a question for your attorney.

If the sibling rents the house out, that’s different. The rule above covers a co-owner who lives there without collecting rents. Rent collected from a tenant is income from the shared property, and the other owners can raise it with the court.

When the house is still in probate or a trust

While the house is in an estate, the personal representative has broader rights than a sibling co-owner would.

  • Possession. Florida law gives a personal representative the right to take possession or control of the decedent’s property, except the protected homestead. The personal representative can leave property with the person presumptively entitled to it, but a written request to deliver it is conclusive evidence that possession is needed for the estate (Fla. Stat. 733.607).
  • Protected homestead is different. A personal representative may take possession of property that appears to be protected homestead only when it isn’t occupied by someone who appears to have an interest in it (Fla. Stat. 733.608). A sibling who is an heir and lives there may fall outside that rule. Ask the attorney.
  • Trusts. In Seaborn, the court noted that while property is in a trust, rent for occupying it would be owed to the trust, not to individual beneficiaries. It cited Kersey v. Abraham (Fla. 6th DCA 2024), where a successor trustee breached her duties by living in the trust property without compensating the trust.

If you need to sell during probate, see the personal representative selling a house and court approval for a probate sale.

Taxes, mortgage and repairs

Who paid the bills often matters more than rent. Florida courts have held that if the co-owner living in the house asks for credit for what they spent preserving it, such as mortgage payments, taxes and insurance, that claim may be offset by the reasonable rental value of the house (Brisciano v. Byard, Fla. 1st DCA 1993, citing Adkins v. Adkins, Fla. 1st DCA 1992).

In plain terms: if the sibling in the house wants the others to chip in for taxes and insurance, the court may weigh what it would have cost them to rent the place. Keep receipts for anything you pay, and write down who paid what and when.

Buyout, sale or partition

Buyout. The sibling who lives there buys the others’ shares, usually by refinancing or with a new loan. Agree on a value first. A licensed appraisal is the cleanest way.

Sell together. Everyone on title signs, the liens and costs are paid at closing, and the proceeds are split by ownership share, with any agreed adjustments for bills paid.

Partition. If you can’t agree, any co-owner can ask a court to divide or sell the property (Fla. Stat. 64.031). When the property is “heirs property,” Florida’s Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act adds a court-ordered appraisal and gives the co-owners who didn’t ask for a sale the first chance to buy out those who did (Fla. Stat. 64.206 and 64.207). See our partition action guide and heirs property in Florida.

How to start the conversation

  • Lead with numbers, not blame. Share a recent value estimate, the tax bill, the insurance quote and the mortgage payoff.
  • Offer choices with dates. For example, “buy us out by a set date, or we list or sell together.”
  • Put agreements in writing. A short written agreement on who pays what while the house sits avoids most fights.
  • Bring in a neutral. A mediator or the probate attorney can often settle what siblings can’t.

Selling with someone still living there. The Building Buyer buys inherited houses in Florida with a family member still living in them. We can work around a move-out date and buy the house as-is with belongings left behind. We pay all closing costs and charge no commissions. Hablamos español. Get my offer or call (954) 478-6769.

Related reading: inherited a house with siblings, inherited house with tenants, and cleaning out a parent’s house.

Frequently asked questions

Can I charge my sibling rent for living in our inherited house in Florida?

Generally not just for living there. Florida courts require ouster, meaning the sibling shut you out or claimed the house as theirs and let you know. A 2025 appeals court decision, Seaborn v. Seaborn, reversed a back-rent award for that reason.

Can I make my sibling move out of the inherited house?

A co-owner generally has the right to live in the house. If it’s still in the estate, the personal representative may be able to take possession, except for protected homestead occupied by an heir. Otherwise, a buyout, a sale or a partition case is usually how it ends. Ask an attorney before you change locks or remove belongings.

My sibling pays nothing toward taxes or insurance. What can I do?

Keep records of what you pay. When the house is sold or partitioned, the court can consider contributions between co-owners, and if the sibling in the house asks for credit for their own payments, the rental value may be offset against that claim.

Can one sibling sell the house without the others?

No. Each co-owner can only sell their own share. To sell the whole house, everyone on title signs, a personal representative sells with authority, or a court orders a sale in a partition case.

Will you buy a house that a sibling is still living in?

Yes, as long as everyone who needs to sign agrees to the sale. We can set the closing around a move-out date and buy the house as-is.

Sources

  1. Seaborn v. Seaborn, No. 2D2024-1323 (Fla. 2d DCA 2025), opinion. Florida Second District Court of Appeal
  2. Brisciano v. Byard, 615 So. 2d 213 (Fla. 1st DCA 1993). Justia
  3. Fla. Stat. 733.607, Possession of estate. Florida Senate
  4. Fla. Stat. 733.608, General power of the personal representative. Florida Senate
  5. Fla. Stat. 64.031, Partition; parties. Florida Senate
  6. Fla. Stat. 64.206, Determination of value (Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act). Florida Senate
  7. Fla. Stat. 64.207, Cotenant buyout. Florida Senate
  8. Fla. Stat. 689.15, Estates by survivorship. Florida Senate

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Please ask your attorney before you file, sign, or sell anything.

What attorneys and sellers say about us.

My experience with Dylan was incredible. He is not only professional, reliable and honest, but Dylan advocated for me during a dark time when I wasn’t sure who I could really count on. I thank my lucky stars I found Dylan and The Building Buyer, he handled the selling of my fathers estate quickly and with dignity and kindness. Call Dylan before you call anyone else, because he can accomplish what other probate agents likely are not willing or able to. I couldn’t recommend them more!
Chrissy Bisch

Coral Springs, FL

My family and I can only say positive things about our experience with Dylan Troiano at “The Building Buyer”. He was a God-send to our family and we are thankful for his thorough, sound knowledge, and advise concerning the sale of an inherited, family home. He knows the market and numbers well and is an honest, dedicated, focused, businessman. My family was given a more-than-fair price, and this company made the sale seamless and easy on us. Dylan is as sharp as they come. Thank you again, for all of the hard work; you are so appreciated.
Lila Whittaker

Griffin, GA

Charles and Dylan know what they want, when they want it and how to get it! My family was tied up with the City for years and years over liens all sorts of red tape. Dylan and Charles got in contact with us and helped facilitate the sale of my family’s house as soon as we possibly could. Offered a very fair price and stuck to their words and offer through the entire process. Thanks guys and good luck with the house and in the future.
Tom Paszko

Buffalo, NY

At first I was skeptical because it seemed too easy, I met with Dylan and he explained everything to me and I had a good feeling ( I had talked/met several people already) then met his partner Charles and made one of the best decisions ever…I went with them…they kept me informed about what was happening and it WAS as easy as they said. I couldn’t be happier. They gave me a fair price and a no-hassle closing. I will recommend Dylan and Charles to anyone who wants a headache-free deal. I got exactly what they promised to me and I can’t be happier
Tracy Rose

Sunrise, FL

The Building Buyer

800 E Broward Blvd Ste 700, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
(954) 478-6769
info@thebuildingbuyer.com
Open 24 Hours

Leave A Message